Historical Homes
Address: 44 Nelson Ave, Cooperstown, NY 13326
Price: $550,000
Bedrooms: 4
Bathrooms: 2
Living Space: 2,264 sq ft
Lot Size: 0.72 acres
Year Built: 1886
Property Type: Single Family Residence
Price per Sq Ft: $243
HOA: Not listed
Zestimate®: $515,500
Listed by:
Stack-Page Properties (607-547-6177)
Denise Page-LaCava (607-316-7474)
Property Link: View Listing on Zillow
Photo Credit: Listing photos provided by MLS via Zillow
1886 Victorian Landmark in Cooperstown’s Historic Village
Nestled in the heart of Cooperstown’s Historic Village, Cherry Hall is a distinguished 1886 Victorian residence celebrated for the rich cherry wood interiors that define its timeless warmth and craftsmanship.
Offering historic architectural detail, generous living spaces, and remarkable restoration potential, this stately home presents a rare opportunity to own a true village landmark within walking distance of Cooperstown’s renowned cultural destinations.
Recently improved with a new 200-amp electrical service, beautifully refinished first-floor hardwood floors, and new carpeting on the second-floor landing, the property is poised for its next chapter.
Interior Highlights
• Four-bedroom layout
• Two bathrooms
• 2,264 sq ft of living space
• Rich original cherry wood interior detailing
• Four fireplaces
• Formal living room with French doors
• Study with pocket doors
• Walk-up attic with three versatile rooms
• One attic room previously used as a home office
• Spacious bedroom closets, including one walk-in closet
• Elegant stained-glass staircase window
• Additional stained-glass accents on second floor
• Walk-out basement family room with bay window
• Original built-in cabinetry
• Former summer kitchen with flexible future use
Exterior & Architectural Features
• Built in 1886
• 0.72-acre village lot
• Front covered porch
• Flagstone patio
• Balcony off dining room overlooking backyard
• One-car garage
• Expansive backyard with room for gardens and recreation
• Classic Victorian architectural presence
Additional Notes
• Back on the market with recent upgrades
• New 200-amp electrical service box
• First-floor hardwood floors recently refinished
• New carpeting on second-floor landing
• Fireplaces currently not operational
• Prime walkable location near Main Street
• Minutes from the Baseball Hall of Fame, Otsego Lake, Fenimore Museum, and Glimmerglass Festival
• Excellent restoration and modernization opportunity
Cherry Hall offers the rare chance to steward a true piece of Cooperstown history. With its gracious proportions, original architectural detail, desirable village setting, and significant potential for thoughtful renewal, this elegant Victorian invites its next owner to restore and reimagine a remarkable historic treasure.
