Historical Homes
Address: 213 Mill St, Theresa, NY 13691
Price: $215,000
Bedrooms: 6
Bathrooms: 3
Living Space: 3,096 sq ft
Lot Size: 0.65 acres
Year Built: 1880
Property Type: Single Family Residence
Price per Sq Ft: $69
HOA: None listed
Zestimate®: $214,900
Listed by:
Joseph Murtha (315-777-4365)
North Star Real Estate & Property Management
Source: Jefferson-Lewis County MLS (MLS#: S1684204) via Zillow
Property Link: https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/213-Mill-St-Theresa-NY-13691/30561992_zpid/
Photo Credit: Listing photos provided by MLS via Zillow
NATIONAL REGISTER HISTORIC QUEEN ANNE – RARE VICTORIAN LANDMARK
Known as the Snell-Gillett House, this 1880-built Queen Anne Victorian is officially listed on the National Register of Historic Places. It stands as one of Theresa, New York’s most architecturally significant historic homes, offering original craftsmanship, grand proportions, and exceptional preservation potential.
With nearly 10-foot ceilings and richly detailed interiors, this residence delivers a true step back into the late 19th century.
INTERIOR HIGHLIGHTS
• 6 bedrooms
• 3 bathrooms
• 3,096 sq ft of living space
• Nearly 10-foot ceilings
• Formal entry hall with chandelier
• Ornately carved staircase
• Two large fireplaces
• Original hardwood flooring throughout
• Stained glass windows and entry doors
• Brass hardware and period fixtures
• Wide pocket doors (5-ft double doors)
HISTORIC ARCHITECTURAL DETAILS
This home is filled with rare original craftsmanship, including:
• Intricately carved mouldings
• Stained glass accent windows
• Ornate brass doorknobs
• Decorative woodwork throughout
• Classic Queen Anne asymmetrical design elements
• Formal Victorian-era layout
Every room reflects authentic 1880s design integrity.
RECENT UPGRADES
• New metal roof (2024)
• New propane fireplace (2024)
• 18 new double-pane second-floor windows (2025)
These updates provide improved efficiency while preserving historic character.
CARRIAGE HOUSE / GARAGE BUILDING
A major bonus is the detached garage/carriage house, previously used as a professional office, featuring:
• Electricity, heat, and plumbing
• 2-car garage capacity
• Upper loft space for finishing
• Flexible use (studio, business, guest space, or workshop)
LOCATION & LIFESTYLE
Located in Theresa, NY, this property offers both charm and convenience:
• Walking distance to Theresa Elementary
• Close to Indian River
• Minutes to 12 nearby lakes
• Easy access to Fort Drum
• Near Thousand Islands & St. Lawrence River region
• Short drive to Watertown
Ideal for those seeking historic living with outdoor recreation access.
A RARE HISTORIC OPPORTUNITY
The Snell-Gillett House combines authentic Queen Anne architecture, modern updates, and flexible space use potential. Whether restored as a private residence, converted for income use, or preserved as a historic showcase, this property offers exceptional long-term value.
A true landmark Victorian with character that cannot be replicated.
